Skip to main content

How to Make the Most of School Counselor Recommendations

Kara Courtois

Written by Kara Courtoison May 10th, 2021

I came to College Coach with a combination of experience in college admissions and teaching in elementary and high schools in Washington D.C., California, and Florida. Upon graduating from the University of Notre Dame, I volunteered as a teacher for two years with an AmeriCorps-sponsored program while earning a master of arts in teaching. Having taught in urban areas with students who had great needs of all varieties, I was honored to transition to working in college admissions at Barnard College. I traveled extensively, recruiting a huge diversity of academically gifted young women from the Midwest, NYC public high schools, and internationally. College admissions at a highly selective college gave me the unique opportunity to mesh my classroom teaching experience with an ability to understand what colleges seek in their students today. Additionally, having been a competitive high school athlete in track followed by rowing on the varsity crew team at Notre Dame, I know the extra demands student athletes juggle. I enjoy helping them figure out how to balance their athletic interests with their academic goals.
Learn More About Kara
by Kara Courtois, former admissions officer at Barnard College It’s common, especially at larger high schools, that school counselors cannot personally know each and every student to whom they are assigned. Given the unreasonable number of students most counselors have in their caseload, this unfortunate situation is not surprising, but this reality has only gotten more challenging because of virtual schooling. Maybe this doesn’t worry you too much as a parent until you realize this same counselor may be required to write a letter of recommendation for your student’s college applications. But don’t panic; it’s not as dire a situation as you might think! Our college admissions experts help students get over this hurdle every year. Though it’s true a personal connection between school counselor and student might be helpful in multiple respects, the purpose of the recommendation letter is not necessarily meant to be personal. What information do school reports (as counselor recommendations are often called) usually provide, then? Colleges are most curious about:
  • How rigorous a 9-12 course load, within the context of the school’s offerings, the applicant took in relation to their classmates
  • Confirmation of any extended absences or difficult life experiences the student gives the counselor permission to reveal or confirm, including ways that COVID may have affected them or their family
  • A broad overview of the student’s activities and most prominent character traits
  • Any other information that may offer context for the student’s choices regarding academics and extra-curriculars
So, unlike teacher recommendation, the counselor recommendation is not expected to show in detail how a student conducts themself in the classroom or how they may approach particular academic subjects. But, information about your child’s contributions to the school overall and how your child might be prepared for the college experience certainly couldn’t hurt. Review the Common App’s own description of what they expect from the letter of recommendation. How can you ensure the counselor has at least some idea of who your student is and what they care about? Here are a few quick tips for how their counselor might get to quickly know your student:
  1. Have your student create a list of the clubs, volunteer work, sports, jobs, etc., they have participated in since 9thgrade, and give a copy to the counselor. Additionally, the counselor may provide what is sometimes called a “brag sheet” that will require the student to list these activities and offers insights into their goals and preferences for college.
  1. Set up an in-person meeting with the counselor and your student at the end of junior year to discuss a college list and the counseling office’s policies around college applications. If your schedule doesn’t allow for this, encourage your student to set up and attend the meeting independently.
  1. Encourage your student to continue to meet or communicate with the counselor on a regular basis throughout the remainder of junior and senior year.
Performing any of the above suggestions will help your counselor along, but being on time with paperwork in the senior year, including letter and transcript requests, is the best way to get on a counselor’s good side. Make sure your student is prepared and check out our college admissions timetable. The early bird gets the worm! College Application Prep 101


Interested in learning more about how our college admissions counseling services can help your student succeed?

Call 877-402-6224 or complete the form for information on getting your student started with one of our experts.

Inclusion Matters Here Pride Flag